Pengulas: Kapal Berita

LIM KIT SIANG CABAR BN SIARKAN TAPE DEBAT PARLIMEN

Hujah Lim Kit Siang ini cukup bernas. Beliau mencabar kerajaan memancarkan rakaman debat parlimen antara Mahfuz dan MP BN Tampin tempoh hari supaya rakyat dapat menjadi hakim siapakah sebenarnya yang berkelakuan gangster (penyangak) dalam parlimen sehingga mengajak bertumbuk.

Sikap media pro kerajaan yang menuduh Mahfuz itu amat mendukacitakan kerana mereka sanggup menipu. Nampaknya akhbar The Sun sahaja yang menunjukkan sikap kewartanan yang jujur:

"Many unparliamentary words were heard and the situation reached its climax when Shahziman Abu Mansor (Tampin) called on Mahfuz to settle the matter physically outside the Dewan." - The Sun

"Banyak perkataan yang tidak beretika parlimen kedengaran dan situasi itu menjadi klimaks (memuncak) bila Shahziman Abu Mansor (Tampin) memanggil Mahfuz untuk menyelesaikan perkara itu secara fizikal di luar dewan"

Minggu lepas PM memberitahu bahawa beliau memerhatikan sidang parlimen melalui satu kamera khas. Oleh itu sewajarnya rakaman video itu dipaparkan kepada rakyat demi kebenaran.

Jika Mahfuzlah punca segala kemelut dan pertengkaran itu, sudah tentu rakaman pita itu sudah dipancar ke seluruh negara. Nampak sangat BN sendiri pun resah kerana wakilnya sendiri yang melakukan aksi yang tidak beretika itu .

DAP National Chairman Lim Kit Siang in Petaling Jaya on Sunday, 12th November 2000:

Telecast the Putrajaya videotaping of Dewan Rakyat ruckus on Wednesday to let the people see for themselves the unparliamentary and gangsterish behaviour of the BN MP for Tampin in challenging Mahfuz Omar to a fistfight outside the House

Parliamentary ruckus - Telecast Putrajaya videotape

The Barisan Nasional government is using its control of the mainstream mass media to distort and cause confusion as to who was the culprit responsible for the worst parliamentary ruckus in Malaysian history on Wednesday during the emergency parliamentary debate on Sunday's police "trigger-happy" firing of tear gas and chemically-laced water cannon, brutality and vandalism against the peaceful crowd at Kesas Highway demanding restoration of the people?s democratic rights.

What transpired during the hour-long emergency debate moved by the PAS MP for Pokok Sena, Mahfuz Omar was best captured by the Sun report of November 9, 2000:

"A debate on policy cruelty during an opposition gathering in Klang last Sunday almost turned violent with a shouting match between government and opposition MPs during the last hour of the sitting.

"The first 30 minutes was filled with heated speeches from Mahfuz Omar (PAS - Pokok Sena), Dr. Tan Seng Giaw (DAP - Kepong) and Abdul Rahman Yusof (Keadilan - Kemamam).

"Backbenchers Datuk Mohd Zin Mohd (BN - Shah Alam) and Datuk Ruhani Ahmad (BN - Parit Sulong) argued back the next half hour, followed by a conclusion from Deputy Home Minister Datuk Zainal Abidin Zin who spoke on behalf of the government.

"Throughout the hour, the House was restless, with MPs from both sides interrupting the debates with shouts and jeers.

"Even Deputy Speaker Datuk Lim Si Cheng appeared unable to control the situation as his voice was drowned out by the others and his orders disobeyed.

"Many unparliamentary words were heard and the situation reached its climax when Shahziman Abu Mansor (Tampin) called on Mahfuz to settle the matter physically outside the Dewan."

It is clear from the accounts I have heard of what transpired in Parliament as well as the official report of the parliamentary proceedings on Wednesday's Hansard that the culprit trying to turn the Dewan Rakyat into a Taiwan-type of legislative chamber where Members of Parliament take the law into their own hands in fisticuffs and physical attacks on each other was none other than the Barisan Nasional MP for Tampin Shahziman Abu Mansor.

It is most regrettable that while expressing their dismay and disapproval at the parliamentary ruckus on Wednesday, neither the Speaker Tan Sir Zahir Ismail nor the Minister in the Prime Minister's Department, Datuk Dr. Rais Yatim had been fair in not pinpointing Shahziman as the culprit who exceeded the bounds of parliamentary propriety in challenging Mahfuz "to settle the matter physically outside the Dewan".

Malaysians, and in particular the voters, are entitled to know who was the culprit who started the parliamentary mayhem on Wednesday and this can easily be done by telecasting the Putrajaya videotaping of the Dewan Rakyat ruckus on Wednesday.

Last week, the Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Dr. Mahathir Mohamad said that he was keeping a close watch on attendance of MPs at the Dewan Rakyat as he has a live video link-up of the proceedings to his office in Putrajaya and that could look into the chamber to see who is talking and who is not and he knows when the room is empty.

Nobody believes that the Prime Minister would have the time to sit in his Putrajaya office to follow the parliamentary proceedings - or he would be guilty of the worst form of parliamentary "truancy" when he should set the example of diligent attendance in Parliament for the Cabinet Ministers and Barisan Nasional MPs.

If the Prime Minister hardly had the time to tune in to the live video hook-up to the parliamentary proceedings from his Putrajaya office, there is even lesser justification for the installation of a closed circuit camera to allow him to snoop at parliamentary proceedings without prior approval or knowledge of Parliament or the nation.

One can only assume that the parliamentary proceedings to Putrajaya are being recorded and taped for viewing by the Prime Minister at his leisure and pleasure.

This is why the Putrajaya videotape of the parliamentary ruckus on Wednesday should be telecast to the nation so that the people can see for themselves the unparliamentary and gangsterish behaviour of the BN MP for Tampin in challenging Mahfuz Omar to a fistfight outside the House.

If it was Mahfuz who had ignited the parliamentary ruckus with unparliamentary and gangsterish provocation against Barisan Nasional MPs to fisticuffs outside the Chamber, this Putrajaya videotape would have been telecast to the nation already.

After the Putrajaya videotape of Shahziman's unparliamentary and gangsterish behaviour in the Dewan Rakyat had been telecast to the nation, the Barisan Nasional MP for Tampin should be referred to the Committee of Privileges for grave breach of parliamentary privilege.